Mexico threatens lawsuit against Google over "Gulf of America" name on Google Maps

midian182

Posts: 10,445   +139
Staff member
In brief: Mexico is not happy about Google changing the name of the Gulf of Mexico to the Gulf of America on Google Maps. The country is now threatening to sue the tech company if it doesn't restore the original name.

Google Maps changed the body of water's name to the Gulf of America earlier this month. It followed President Trump's proclamation that decreed the renaming and the subsequent name change by the federal Board on Geographic Names.

Mexico's president Claudia Sheinbaum said on Monday that Trump's order only applies to the part of continental shelf under US control, which extends 22 nautical miles from the US coast – not the entire Gulf. But Google is changing the name of the portion of the Gulf that includes Mexico's and Cuba's continental shelves.

Mexico argues that the policy violates Mexican sovereignty as the US has jurisdiction over around 46% of the Gulf, while Mexico controls 49% and Cuba controls 5%.

"We do not agree with this, and the Foreign Minister has sent a new letter addressing the issue," Sheinbaum said. The letter states that under no circumstances does Mexico accept the renaming of any geographic area that includes part of its national territory and that is under its jurisdiction.

The letter to Google adds that "any reference to the 'Gulf of America' initiative on your Google Maps platform must be strictly limited to the marine area under U.S. jurisdiction."

"Any extension beyond that zone exceeds the authority of any national government or private entity. Should that be the case, the Government of Mexico will take the appropriate legal actions as deemed necessary," it states.

Although Google Maps users in the US now see the Gulf of America name, it appears as Gulf of Mexico to those in Mexico. The rest of the world sees both names on Google Maps.

Sheinbaum said last week that a civil suit could be launched against Google if it did not correct what she called an "inaccurate designation."

The Mexican government has been in talks with Google over the issue since January. It will wait for the company's response to the letter before proceeding with any legal action.

Google says the name change on Maps is part of its long-standing policy of adhering to official government names for locations and other geographical features.

Cris Turner, Google's vice president of government affairs and public policy, told Sheinbaum's government that Google was willing to meet in person but would not change its policy.

"While international treaties and conventions are not intended to regulate how private mapping providers represent geographic features, it is our consistent policy to consult multiple authoritative sources to provide the most up to date and accurate representation of the world," he said.

When Trump first announced the renaming plans ahead of his inauguration, Sheinbaum remarked that Google should rename North America to "América Mexicana," or "Mexican America," because an 1814 founding document that preceded Mexico's constitution referred to it that way.

Permalink to story:

 
It will be extremely interesting to see what sort of legal action Mexico launches. The ICC certainly doesn't cover this sort of thing and since Google is already complying with the laws in both USA and Mexico, in which jurisdiction Mexico chooses to launch the action will be intriguing.
 
It will be extremely interesting to see what sort of legal action Mexico launches. The ICC certainly doesn't cover this sort of thing and since Google is already complying with the laws in both USA and Mexico, in which jurisdiction Mexico chooses to launch the action will be intriguing.

No depending on what it's worth fund they just choose to take Google can choose to ignore them too Google can do a lot more harm shutting down their search engine in their services in Mexico inconsiderably powerful message to the Mexican government.

This is all smoking mirrors cuz she's upset that it's been pointed out to everybody how easy on crime she is and how complicit she is with the cartels this is her way of distracting from the actual problem and that's that her government has been lacks and enforcement and she likely takes kickbacks from the cartel
 
As much as I respect the reaction from Mexico, I think they are being very optimistic thinking they will be successful against the corporate might of bullies such as Google, and Trump.
Mexico's president doesn't have to be succesful - she only needs to be seen going up against Google and Trump as candle86 already indicated.
Personally I'd like to see this bs reversed and furthermore, should Mexico's president win in court there's no doubt in my mind Google won't fight the decision. Google only did this to avoid getting into Trump-trouble.
 
This whole issue was created to distract from actual policies… Trump doesn’t give a *%^% about the gulf’s name - he did it to distract Americans… I suspect that Claudia ALSO doesn’t give a *^%* about it - but her citizens also need distracting (as a previous user already stated).

Suing Google will do nothing - it’s not Google who has to be convinced - it’s Trump… and he won’t change it back unless he gets something in return… much like the tariffs on Canada and Mexico - this is simply a business move.
 
Trump is just doing all this stupid insane crap, so you don't see what Musk is really doing.
Wake up people, get your head out of the sand.
When are you people gonna realize the New Nazi Party is trying to take over the world.

Stand up for yourself and take back your country. Your running out of time.
No wonder people around the world think Americans are weak and lazy.
 
Trump is just doing all this stupid insane crap, so you don't see what Musk is really doing.
Wake up people, get your head out of the sand.
When are you people gonna realize the New Nazi Party is trying to take over the world.

Stand up for yourself and take back your country. Your running out of time.
No wonder people around the world think Americans are weak and lazy.
That would be socialism, not capitalism.
 
Next up is: Change the name of the color «Orange» - to «Tremendous» - so everyone has to say he has Tremendous Skin
They should force Trump to change his name back to Drumpf which is what it was before his grandfather changed it to avoid anti-German sentiment after WWII. Also, they should revoke Melania's citizenship and deport her. She's been in the US for almost 25 years and can't even speak proper English. Be Best!

Let's see how many Trump cultists I can trigger.

PS. - I heard Drumpf is going to rename Canada to America Junior.
 
Last edited:
Trump·er·y
/ˈtrəmp(ə)rē/
archaic
noun
noun: trumpery; plural noun: trumperies

-attractive articles of little value or use.
"None of your woolen drapery, nor linen drapery, nor any of your frippery or trumpery. I hate ostentation"

-practices or beliefs that are superficially or visually appealing but have little real value or worth.
"he exposed their ideals as trumpery"

adjective
adjective: trumpery

-showy but worthless.
"trumpery jewelry"
 
This is such a stupid thing to be focused on.

I don't suffer from TDS unlike a lot of people around here but this is one of those things I just don't understand.
 
Trump is just doing all this stupid insane crap, so you don't see what Musk is really doing.
Wake up people, get your head out of the sand.
When are you people gonna realize the New Nazi Party is trying to take over the world.

Stand up for yourself and take back your country. Your running out of time.
No wonder people around the world think Americans are weak and lazy.
I can't tell if you're serious or trolling because there is so much crazy around here.
 
Mexico is part of North AMERICA. The shores of the gulf in question exist in several North American nations. Therefore, the name "Gulf of Mexico" is geologically inaccurate and socially inappropriate. Renaming it to the "Gulf of America" corrects a problem that has existed for a lot longer than it needed to.

Mexico needs to get the hell over it and STHU.
 
Mexico is part of North AMERICA. The shores of the gulf in question exist in several North American nations. Therefore, the name "Gulf of Mexico" is geologically inaccurate and socially inappropriate. Renaming it to the "Gulf of America" corrects a problem that has existed for a lot longer than it needed to.

Mexico needs to get the hell over it and STHU.
It’s still named The Gulf of Mexico in 98% of the world. And like - countries are free to call places whatever they like - But the international name will still remain Gulf of Mexico (although I agree that the new naming is geographically more correct ..not so sure about «socially» as I can see 0 situations where the name of a body of water would be socially inappropriate)
 
Back